Digitalizing Public Services in Supporting Economic Development: The Case of Viet Nam

Announcing: Walsh, John, “Digitalizing Public Services in Supporting Economic Development: The Case of Viet Nam,” in Lurong Chen and Fukunari Kimura, eds., Empowering Online Public Services in Asia: The Digital Frontier (Jakarta: Economic Research Institute for ASEAN and East Asia, 2024), pp.149-76, available at: https://www.eria.org/uploads/DIGIGOV-FULL-15March2024.pdf.

There will be a printed version soon. In lieu of an abstract, here is the beginning of the introduction:

In common with many other one-party nations, Viet Nam has appointed the ruling Vietnamese
Communist Party to play a leading role in enacting state-level developmental goals. It has also
followed the policy of creating large-scale plans for the transformation of the economy and society
in dimensions considered to be of strategic importance. In the case of digitisation, this is being
accomplished through the National Digital Transformation Programme (NDTP), which has strict
prescriptions up to 2025 and a vision towards 2030 (Vietnam Briefing, 2021). The plan contains a wide
variety of measurable targets and milestones, with some aimed at incorporating more Vietnamese
people into a developing, prosperous, and modern country, and others deepening the existing economic
model of reliance on inward investment. In the first category, it is planned that 50% of customers’
banking operations will be fully online, 50% of customers will have a digital checking account, and
80% of online public services at level 41 will be available through access to mobile devices. In the
second category, the digital economy should contribute 20% of the total economy by 2025 and 30% by
2030 (it is currently 5%), while Viet Nam should be listed in the top 50 countries of the UN ICT Index by
2025 (Vietnam Briefing, 2021). To ensure these goals are met, a committee has been established, with
16 members, including the Prime Minister and representatives from a wide range of ministries and
agencies. Named the National Committee on Digital Transformation, it will have the tasks of bringing
about administrative reform, implementing the NDTP, developing e-government and society and smart
cities, and monitoring the implementation of the National Strategy of the Fourth Industrial Revolution
(Dharmaraj, 2021b). Clearly, these are wide-ranging responsibilities, and it will be hard for any group
of people to fulfil such complex responsibilities. The situation is made more difficult because of the
current environment, which contains several dangerous if not existential threats, such as the ongoing
coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, the climate emergency, and rising international tensions
focusing on the relationship between the United States (US) and China, as well as Russia’s invasion of
Ukraine. Under these circumstances, it would be useful to try to identify exactly what the NDTP means
in terms of the definition of digitalisation, the forms that it takes with respect to different stakeholders
across the country, and the challenges that are likely to be faced (although the possibility of suggesting
solutions to such problems is likely to be beyond the scope of a chapter of this sort). The purpose
of this chapter, therefore, is to map the extent to which digitalisation policies have been established
and implemented in Viet Nam and, more importantly, to establish the gaps that exist in everyday life
between what is being made available for people and their experience of those opportunities. It is
argued that the gaps that do exist are likely to intensify existing problems of inequality in Vietnamese
society but that the government nevertheless will continue to pursue them to achieve the desired level
of economic growth.

Digital Transformation in Vietnamese SMEs

New details (volume, number, page numbers) for this paper have been provided, which is an excuse to puff this one again:

Walsh, John, Trung, Nguyen Quang and Thinh Hoang (2023), “Digital Transformation in Vietnamese SMEs: Managerial Implications,” Journal of Internet and Digital Economics, Vol.3, No.1/2. Pp.18-32. DOI: 10.1108/JIDE-09-2022-0018; available at: https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JIDE-09-2022-0018/full/html.

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to investigate the implementation of digital transformation in small and medium-sized enterprises in Vietnam.

Design/methodology/approach

The research features in-depth personal interviews with SME executives and managers.

Findings

The findings of this study may be summarized into five main areas: (1) multi-tasking role and scarcity of resources; (2) risk; (3) data-driven decision-making processes; (4) efficient communications; and (5) strategic issues. These categories emerged from the content analysis process.

Research limitations/implications

Qualitative research provides a good explanation for situations in actual firms but may not always be generalizable.

Practical implications

Means of overcoming problems with implementing digital transformation in Vietnamese SMEs are provided.

Originality/value

Most studies of Vietnamese companies focus on intensive manufacturing and membership in supply chains. Few studies consider the emergent service and technology sector.

Keywords

My Interview with UEB Is Published

I was interviewed by University of Economics and Business (Vietnam) on the subject of “Promoting the Effectiveness of the UK-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement in a Strong Bilateral Relationship,” available at: https://youtu.be/auDG95Di6HA.

It’s me, recorded on my laptop in my Krirk cubicle.

Available for birthdays and celebratory rituals of all types.

Vietnam and the Specter of Deglobalization

Announcing: Walsh, John, “Vietnam and the Specter of Deglobalization,” Suvannabhumi: Multi-disciplinary Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, Vol.15, No.2 (2023), pp.23-55. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22801/svn.2023.15.2.23.

Just as globalization has many aspects and has developed in various, sometimes contradictory ways with both positive and negative impacts, so too would the reverse process of deglobalization have wide-ranging effects for individuals, communities, and nations. Some parts of globalization began to fray during the coronavirus pandemic (e.g. failing supply chains and disarray in the global shipping industry). Deglobalization would bring about much more significant changes in focusing on local production and consumption, eschewing non-essential flights and international tourism, and replacing personal experience with virtual presence. These impacts would be particularly severe for Vietnam, since its government has placed intensive connectivity with global production at the center of its model for the rapid development on which much of its legitimacy rests and it has joined as many international, multilateral organizations, and protocols as it has been able to do. Through critical analysis of secondary data from a wide range of sources, this paper examines the motivations that people, institutions, and governments might have to pursue deglobalization  and then seeks evidence for whether the changes that would bring have started to affect Vietnam. While it is difficult to be too certain about this while the pandemic continues, it is evident that pressures are building in the global north to reconfigure supply chains for greater security, to reduce carbon emissions through regulating long-distance exchanges, and to withdraw from personal contacts. It is argued that a focus on digitalization in economy and society will help to mitigate the negative effects of deglobalization on Vietnam, at least in the medium-term.

Keywords: deglobalization, digitalization, economic development, globalization, Vietnam


Yes, I know it should be ‘spectre’ (as in Rector vs Spectre) but the journal is based in Korea so I have to use American spelling (the title of course refers to the Communist Manifesto).

Education Development to Enhance Internationalization

Yesterday, I had the opportunity to address a group of representatives of educational institutions across ASEAN with a view to encouraging them to contribute to recruiting new students for Krirk University and, specifically, the English Language Programs at the International College, for which I am the director.

So, of course, I did. I thought it went well and we got a number of new Memorandums* of Understanding with people from Vietnam, Myanmar, Cambodia and others. Let’s hope new students start to flood in very soon.

*Memoranda if you prefer.

Creativity and Economic Growth: The Case of Vietnam

This afternoon I had the honour of presenting a keynote address at the 1st Seminar on Talent Training and High-Level Opening Development in International Trade hosted by Nanyang Institute of Management in Singapore (I joined online).

I spoke on the subject of creativity and economic growth and used the example of Vietnam to explain the situation in real life. The basis of the address was that economic growth was divided into two phases, import substitution and innovation. Import-substitution in the form of intensive manufacturing can bring a country from low-income to middle-income status but innovation is required to achieve high-income status. However, there are countries (e.g. Vietnam) where the government does not want to grant the kinds of personal freedoms we normally associate with the ability of people to innovate. Consequently, in order to spur innovation, the focus (in business schools) is on creativity as a small-team activity that can be taught, monitored and measured. Hence, we in this field fulfil what Bourdieu said about the purpose of education: to recreate the existing social relations.

Digital Transformation in Vietnamese SMEs: Managerial Implications

Announcing: Trung, Nguyen Quang, John Walsh and Thinh Hoang (2023), “Digital Transformation in Vietnamese SMEs: Managerial Implications,” Journal of Internet and Digital Economics, DOI: 10.1108/JIDE-09-2022-0018; available at: https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JIDE-09-2022-0018/full/html.

Abstract:

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to investigate the implementation of digital transformation in small and medium-sized enterprises in Vietnam.

Design/methodology/approach

The research features in-depth personal interviews with SME executives and managers.

Findings

The findings of this study may be summarized into five main areas: (1) multi-tasking role and scarcity of resources; (2) risk; (3) data-driven decision-making processes; (4) efficient communications; and (5) strategic issues. These categories emerged from the content analysis process.

Research limitations/implications

Qualitative research provides a good explanation for situations in actual firms but may not always be generalizable.

Practical implications

Means of overcoming problems with implementing digital transformation in Vietnamese SMEs are provided.

Originality/value

Most studies of Vietnamese companies focus on intensive manufacturing and membership in supply chains. Few studies consider the emergent service and technology sector.

Keywords: corporate governance; digital transformation; leadership; SMEs; Vietnam

Digital Transformation in Vietnamese SMEs: Managerial Implications

Announcing: Trung, Nguyen Quang, John Walsh and Thinh Hoang, “Digital Transformation in Vietnamese SMEs: Managerial Implications,” Journal of Internet and Digital Economics, DOI: 10.1108/JIDE-09-2022-0018. Forthcoming.

Abstract:

Digital transformation (DT) is a set of processes, tools and services which can represent sources of competitive advantage for firms. When firms are parts of supply or value chains, then they may be required to undertake DT so as to continue membership of the chain. DT comes in many shapes and forms and finding a suitable configuration for a firm can be a complex undertaking. Employing primary qualitative data as a part of a project on the DT of Firms in Vietnam by the RMIT-KPMG Centre of Governance, this study aims not only to shed light on these challenges but also provide suitable recommendations for the SMEs in Vietnam. It also contributes to the emerging literature of the interplay of DT and leadership in SMEs. It is shown that the sample demonstrated lack of resources, including time and skilled personnel, which hampered the ability to undergo DT. Management techniques and competencies are limited such that even when DT is attempted, its benefits are not realized.

Keywords: corporate governance, digital transformation, leadership, SMEs, Vietnam

Skills, Education and Economic Development: Vietnam in Regional Context

Announcing: Walsh, John and Quyen Dang Thao, “Skills, Education and Economic Development: Vietnam in Regional Context,” paper presented at the 3rd Vietnam-Japan International Business Conference (Hanoi: Foreign Trade University, March 17th, 2023).

Abstract:

The search for understanding of how economic development (as measured by increase in GDP and other metrics) takes place has been undertaken for several decades, without conclusive results. It is evident that, although some factors are relatively consistent over time and space, other factors vary significantly with respect to where and when they take place. Among these factors, it is evident that educational outcomes and skills are vital to the formation of a productive labour force but it is not clear whether these should be regarded as consistently important or among those factors which wax and wane in relevance depending on circumstances. This paper explores the case of Vietnam, in regional perspective, to try to understand the importance of educational outcomes and skills in its own labour force under circumstances of export-oriented manufacturing and assembly through quantitative analysis of open source data provided by reputable sources (e.g. UNICEF, World Bank). A regional perspective is chosen to help understand the different forces acting upon the country and what alternatives may be open to it. The results are used to create models of labour force development which may be beneficial for the country and policy suggestions are derived from this process.

Keywords: education outcomes, labour force, regional perspective, skills, Vietnam

In fact, although the paper was accepted for presentation at the conference and apparently is included in the proceedings, they did not actually give us a time to present. Perhaps they just forgot. Never mind, I didn’t have to pay.

Prospects and Problems of Developing a Cashew Nut Export Industry for Lao PDR

Announcing: Walsh, John and Nittana Southiseng, “Prospects and Problems of Developing a Cashew Nut Export Industry for Lao PDR,” paper presented at the 7th International Conference on Lao Studies (online) (Deakin University, 15th-18th, November, 2022).

Abstract:

One important means of developing the Lao economy is by creating export sectors in which local producers can hope for comparative advantage for geographic and climatic reasons. One possible such sector is cashew nuts (Anacardium occidentale), which are nutritious and in increasing demand for incorporation into a wide range of snack foods. Snack foods have historically been the preserve of developed countries but, as urban middle classes emerge across Asia, including Southeast Asia, more markets are opening to which Lao producers might think of aiming their goods. Although the shelling and processing stages are complex and time-consuming, there are prospects for using different parts of the plant and the cashew apple for additional revenue streams. However, there is the problem that mainland Southeast Asia’s cashew nut processing and exporting are dominated by Vietnam, which is one of the world’s leading producers of shelled nuts. Since Vietnam’s processing capacity greatly exceeds its growing capacity, its firms import large numbers of nuts from a range of overseas countries. This includes Cambodia, which exports nearly all of its increasingly large crop of nuts to Vietnam and, since Vietnam has not yet developed popular and established brands which might provide premium levels of pricing, its exporters buy nuts on a low-cost commodity basis. Since cashew growing as an export industry is still in its infancy in Lao PDR, it is worth considering what would need to be done to prevent growers simply acting as a source of cheap inputs for Vietnamese buyers and what support the government might provide to enable local growers to add value to their production and, thereby, maximise the benefit of production.

If anyone is interested in the presentation, then please let me know. I also chaired a session on Lao history and another on art and culture in the country, both of which were very interesting. If you have chance to take a look at any of the recorded sessions or the various exhibitions, then I would recommend that you do so.